Short answer: outsourcing usually makes sense when your in-house billing costs more per dollar collected than a billing company would charge, or when denials and aging A/R are growing faster than your team can work them. In-house billing makes sense when you already have an experienced, stable team, strong reporting and enough volume to keep them fully used.
The mistake most practices make is comparing a billing company's fee with one biller's salary. That leaves out most of what in-house billing actually costs. This guide lists every cost category, explains outsourced pricing models, and gives you a formula to calculate your own number with your own data.
What in-house medical billing really costs
An in-house billing department is a small business unit inside your practice. To compare it fairly with outsourcing, add up every cost it creates over a full year, not only the line on the payroll report:
- Salaries: every billing, coding, payment posting, A/R follow-up and front-desk role that spends time on billing work. Count partial roles too, such as a manager who spends part of the week on billing.
- Benefits: health insurance, retirement contributions, paid time off and any other benefits.
- Payroll taxes: the employer share of payroll taxes and unemployment insurance.
- Training and continuing education: coding credential renewals, annual code-update training, payer policy webinars and the time staff spend away from claims while training.
- Software and clearinghouse fees: practice management or billing software, clearinghouse transaction fees, eligibility tools, claim scrubbers, coding references and patient statement printing or postage.
- Turnover and coverage gaps: recruiting and onboarding a replacement, the learning curve of a new biller, and the claims that sit unworked during vacations, sick leave or vacancies.
- Management time: the hours an office manager, physician or owner spends supervising billing, answering billing questions and reviewing reports.
- Space and equipment: workstations, phones and office space, if they would otherwise be used for something else.
How outsourced medical billing is priced
Billing companies use three main pricing models, and some combine them:
- Percentage of collections: the company earns a share of what it actually collects, commonly 4% to 10% of net collections depending on specialty, volume, payer mix and scope. The company is paid more only when you are.
- Per-claim fee: a fixed price for each claim submitted. Predictable, but the fee is earned whether or not the claim is paid, so follow-up incentives are weaker.
- Flat monthly fee: a set retainer for a defined scope. More common for small, stable practices or for single services.
In-house vs. outsourced billing at a glance
- Cost structure: in-house is mostly fixed (salaries, software, overhead whether claims go out or not); outsourced is mostly variable (usually a percentage of collections).
- Staffing risk: in-house depends on a few people and stalls when one leaves or is out; an outsourced team spreads the work across several staff.
- Expertise: in-house staff learn your practice deeply but may see only a few payers and code sets; a billing company sees denial patterns across many practices and payers.
- Control and visibility: in-house gives direct, day-to-day control; outsourced control depends on the reporting and system access written into the contract.
- Technology: in-house means you buy and maintain software and clearinghouse connections; many billing companies work in your system or supply their own tools.
- Scaling: adding providers or locations in-house means hiring; an outsourced team usually scales without new hires on your side.
- Compliance: either way the practice remains responsible for its claims; an outsourced partner must sign a HIPAA Business Associate Agreement.
How to calculate your own in-house cost per dollar collected
You can compare options with a single number: what it costs you to collect one dollar. Use your own figures for the last 12 months.
Step 1, total annual billing cost (C): add salaries (S), benefits (B), payroll taxes (T), training and education (E), software and clearinghouse fees (F), and an estimate of management time (M), valued at the hourly cost of the person doing it. C = S + B + T + E + F + M.
Step 2, annual net collections (N): the money actually received from payers and patients for the year, from your practice management reports.
Step 3, cost to collect: divide C by N. The result is the share of every collected dollar you spend on billing. Multiply by 100 to express it as a percentage.
Illustrative example only (hypothetical numbers, not benchmarks): if C were $90,000 and N were $1,200,000, your in-house cost to collect would be 90,000 / 1,200,000 = 0.075, or 7.5% of collections. Replace both numbers with your own.
Step 4, compare like with like: a billing company quote of X% of net collections can be compared directly with your cost to collect. Then adjust for collection performance. If a partner would raise net collections (for example by working denials your team does not reach), its fee applies to a larger number, but you also keep more revenue.
Be honest with the inputs. Leaving out management time, turnover or uncollected denials makes in-house billing look cheaper than it is.
The hybrid model: outsource only denials or A/R
Outsourcing does not have to be all or nothing. Many practices keep charge entry and front-desk work in-house and hand off the parts that need the most specialized, persistent effort:
- Denial management and appeals, where payer-specific knowledge matters most.
- Aging A/R follow-up, especially claims over 60 or 90 days old.
- Old A/R cleanup after a system change or staff departure.
- Coding review or credentialing, priced as separate services.
Questions to ask a medical billing company
- Will you sign a HIPAA Business Associate Agreement before you access any patient data?
- Is your percentage applied to net collections or gross charges, and what exactly is included in the fee?
- Which reports will we receive (denial rate, days in A/R, net collection rate, aging by payer), and how often?
- Do you work in our practice management system or yours? Who owns the data, and in what format do we get it back?
- What are the contract length, notice period and exit terms? Who works the claims still open when the contract ends?
- Are there setup fees, monthly minimums or separate charges for old A/R, patient statements or credentialing?
- Who is our point of contact, and how quickly do you respond to questions?
When in-house billing makes sense
If most of these are true, improving your current team, or adding a hybrid arrangement for denials, may be the better path. If few of them are true, outsourcing is worth pricing out.
- You have experienced billing staff with low turnover and documented processes.
- Your claim volume is large enough to keep a full team busy, with cross-training to cover absences.
- Your cost to collect, net collection rate and days in A/R are already strong, and you track them monthly.
- You want billing staff working side by side with clinicians on documentation every day.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to outsource medical billing or do it in-house?
It depends on your numbers. Add up all in-house costs (salaries, benefits, payroll taxes, training, software, clearinghouse fees and management time), divide by annual net collections, and compare the result with outsourced quotes, which commonly fall between 4% and 10% of net collections.
What are the risks of outsourcing medical billing?
The main risks are less day-to-day visibility, poor reporting, unclear data ownership and hard-to-exit contracts. A signed Business Associate Agreement, defined monthly reports, system access and clear exit terms reduce those risks.
What are the risks of in-house medical billing?
Dependence on a few people, coverage gaps during absences or turnover, the cost of keeping up with coding and payer changes, and denials or aging claims that an overloaded team never reaches.
Can I outsource only part of my medical billing?
Yes. A hybrid model is common: the practice keeps registration and charge entry in-house and outsources denial management, A/R follow-up, coding review or credentialing.
How do I calculate my cost to collect?
Divide your total annual billing cost (salaries, benefits, payroll taxes, training, software, clearinghouse fees and management time) by your annual net collections. Multiply by 100 to express it as a percentage of collections.
Does the practice still own its data if billing is outsourced?
It should. Confirm in the contract that the practice owns all patient and financial data and that the billing company will return it in a usable format when the contract ends.
The right choice is the one with the lowest true cost to collect and the highest net collections, not the lowest fee or the smallest payroll. Run the formula with your own numbers before you decide.
Alpha Medi Assist offers a free billing assessment: we review your denials and aging A/R and give you a clear, fixed quote so you can compare it with your in-house cost.

